A Spanish court has granted precautionary measures against NordVPN and ProtonVPN, ordering the two popular VPN providers to block 16 websites that facilitate piracy of football matches.
The restrictions will apply to a dynamic list of IP addresses in Spain, and there will be no opportunity for appeals. The measures were taken ‘inaudita parte’, meaning that the defendants weren’t called to participate in a hearing.
LaLiga – the country’s professional football organizer, and its broadcasting partner, Telefónica, are required to “preserve sufficient digital evidence of the unlawful transmission of the protected contents.”
LaLiga showed a strong stance against the piracy ecosystem in recent years, previously targeting Cloudflare, accusing the internet giant of facilitating illegal sports streaming.
The two organizations proved that the VPN providers fall under the EU Digital Services Regulation, and therefore have a duty to help prevent copyright infringement carried out through their infrastructure.
“The orders identify how VPN systems prove to be a suitable means, ‘highly effective and accessible to generate the possibility of access to content not accessible in certain geographic points,’ distorting the real geographic location of online access, and facilitating ‘access to websites that broadcast protected content illegally,’” reads LaLiga’s announcement.
“What is more, the orders highlight how the defendant companies acknowledge and even advertise that their system is excellent at evading restrictions.”
LaLiga characterized the ruling as unprecedented in Spain, aligning it with similar decisions in France, and celebrated that the liability of VPN providers for piracy is clearly recognized.
In response, ProtonVPN took to Twitter to question the decision, declaring a total lack of awareness of the proceedings and stating that they have not been formally notified.
“Any judicial order issued without proper notification to the affected parties, thereby denying them the opportunity to be heard, would be procedurally invalid under fundamental principles of due process, stated the VPN service provider.
“Spanish courts, like all courts operating under the rule of law, are bound by procedural safeguards that ensure parties are given a fair opportunity to present their case before any binding judgment is rendered.”
In a request for comments to BleepingComputer, NordVPN’s spokesperson Laura Tyrylyte stated that the company was not involved in any legal proceedings in Spain.
“At this stage, we have not received the judicial documents mentioned in the press so it will be premature to comment without having reviewed them. We were not part of any Spanish judicial proceedings to our knowledge, and therefore had no opportunity to defend ourselves. Given such judgments impact on how the Internet operates, such an approach by rightsholders is unacceptable” – NordVPN
Tyrylyte stated that the process for blocking domains is ineffective in the fight against piracy as it does not address the root cause. Instead, hosting providers should be the target, since pirates can use subdomains to bypass the restrictions.
“Effective piracy control should focus on eliminating the source of the content, targeting hosting providers, cutting off financing for illegal operations, and increasing the availability of legitimate content.”
Through its representative, NordVPN said that the measures affect mostly reputable, paid VPN providers, while free services continue to operate largely unhindered.
“Free VPNs are often harder to regulate and, since users who seek to avoid paying for content are unlikely to pay for a VPN either, these services remain a loophole for pirates to bypass restrictions.”
Modern IT infrastructure moves faster than manual workflows can handle.
In this new Tines guide, learn how your team can reduce hidden manual delays, improve reliability through automated response, and build and scale intelligent workflows on top of tools you already use.